News & Insights

Helping People and Companies Thrive Through Empowered Financial Solutions

Trick or treat?” is an easy choice. “Traditional or Roth?” may take more thought, but it doesn’t have to be scary. Let’s dive into the differences between Traditional and Roth deferrals. 

When you put money into a standard investment account, you get taxed multiple times. A regular investment account is funded with money you’ve already paid income tax on, and you also owe tax on the dividends, interest, and gains it earns. Retirement accounts (IRAs, 401(k)s, 403(b)s) give you a tax break instead. Traditional and Roth differ in when you get that break: Traditional gives it to you now, and Roth gives it to you later.  

Demystifying Deferrals 

With a traditional deferral, the money is placed in your plan before you pay income tax on it. In fact, traditional deferrals into your plan are not classified as earned income and therefore lower your taxable liability for the year.  

The benefit of Roth is that when you reach retirement age, you are able to withdraw your money tax-free so long as it meets certain conditions. To take out Roth earnings tax-free, your Roth account must have been open for at least 5 tax years. The clock starts on January 1 of the year you make your first Roth contribution, no matter what month you contribute. A first contribution anytime in 2026 means the 5 years are met on January 1, 2031. You must also be at least age 59½, or the withdrawal must be due to death or disability. 

How do I decide which option is right for me? 

There’s no single right answer. These factors all play a part: 

  • Time horizon: The longer your money has to grow, the more a Roth’s tax-free growth is worth. 
  • Your paycheck today: Traditional lowers your taxable income, so the same contribution takes less out of your take-home pay than Roth does. Pick the one that lets you save an amount you can keep up. 
  • Flexibility: Having both types lets you choose which bucket to draw from each year, which helps you manage your taxable income in retirement. 
  • Tax rates: If you expect to be in a higher bracket in retirement, Roth may come out ahead. If you expect a lower one, Traditional may. Nobody knows future rates for sure, so treat this as one input, not the whole decision. 

Getting Started 

By default, all workplace retirement plans allow you to put your money in post-tax (Traditional). Not all workplace retirement plans allow for Roth, so check with your HR department to see if that provision is available. 

If both Roth and Traditional are available, you can defer to one, the other, or even both at the same time. If your employer puts a contribution into your account on your behalf, that money will always be classified as Traditional, so you’ll have to pay taxes on those during retirement.  

As always, if you have any questions about the differences between Traditional and Roth, or any questions about retirement plans in general, give us a call! We’re happy to help.  

you are leaving the Shepherd Financial Website

you are leaving the Shepherd Financial Website

Connect with a
Member of Our Team